Showing posts with label In-Depth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label In-Depth. Show all posts

Sunday, May 17, 2009

Magazines count the cost of survival

The sector has been hit by falling sales and rising paper costs, but Philip Chadwick finds printers are helping publishers find ways of cutting costs
Magazines are feeling the squeeze right now. With dwindling circulations and advertising at an all-time low, publishers are having to take tough decisions on titles' futures and there have been some high-profile casualties over the past few months. That trend is likely to continue as the market continues to struggle and the print industry is already feeling the knock-on effect.

A snapshot of the sector doesn't make for comfortable reading. One of the highest profile losses was men's glossy Arena, which was suspended in March. The title's circulation was falling and a sharp decline in advertising was one of the reasons for Bauer Media's decision to cease publication. Meanwhile, Dennis Publishing made the decision to shut men's lifestyle magazine Maxim in April. Circulation of the title had dipped by more than 40% and Dennis decided that the future of the brand was online.

In the same month, the free commuter magazine Sport ceased publication after its French parent company Sport Media & Strategy went into administration. St Ives printed 300,000 copies of the weekly title, although there are hopes that it could return in the future, with directors in the UK rethinking the business model and looking for
further investment.

With advertising down and sales on the wane, the situation looks bleak, but publishers and printers are collaborating to ensure that their magazines survive. And some sectors aren't as adversely affected as you might think - there are plenty of signs of life in contract publishing, for example.

Data evidence
The latest set of ABC figures confirm the anomalous activity of customer magazines. In the last six months of 2008, there was a 16% rise in customer publishing titles' circulations and these titles accounted for 12 of the top 20 magazines in terms of circulation. In contrast, consumer magazines experienced a 6.8% circulation drop in the period.

There are also some sectors in the consumer market that are performing better than others. Personal finance titles performed well, as did those in the hobbies sector. But the recession has bitten into reader numbers for men's magazines Nuts and Zoo, while issue circulation for the women's weeklies have dropped 2.6%.

Despite these conflicting fortunes, there were still two notable launches this year, both from the Condé Nast stable. Printed by St Ives Plymouth, monthly Wired and 334pp luxury biannual title Love both hit the newsstands last month. So, while there is no doubt that the recession has taken its hold on magazines, some sectors look like they are coping better than others.

"We see a whole cross-section of the market - we're not a bad barometer," explains Tony Jones, chief executive at Pensord, which prints more than 300 titles, predominately in the B2B sector. "Not all sectors are underperforming but, by our calculations, the titles we have been printing year-on-year are underperforming as a whole."

He adds that smaller publishers appear to be more vulnerable to market fluctuations. "It is almost certain that they do not have much of an asset base and the last thing a printer wants is to effectively become their bankers. As we approach the summer, it seems increasingly likely that there will be more casualties," says Jones.

Helping hand
Pensord is doing its hardest to help publishers so that they can keep hold of the titles they've got. It's all about saving money in areas such as the design or the paper grammage, according to Jones.

"These days, it appears there are fewer experienced print buyers, particularly in smaller publishing companies. Therefore, many of the communications we receive start with ‘Can you reduce your prices?'," says Jones. "Our responses are often far more detailed than just a yes or a no. Long before the recession started, we made a conscious decision to put in place a print buyers' health check service to make sure publishers are buying cost effectively and efficiently in all areas."

Polestar is another print firm that handles both production and mailing for a number of its magazine clients. The company feels that it is well placed to work with clients on areas where cost savings can be made.

"With recent changes to the postal tariff, we have seen a move towards a lighter grade of paper being used for subscription copies of magazines to help reduce mailing costs," explains Polestar UK print key account director Avril Jenkins. "We have worked with our customers to trial various weights and brands of paper to ensure we achieve the best results."

The importance of paper isn't lost on the publishers themselves. Emap manufacturing director Richard Hunt recently outlined how the company's Inform stable of B2B magazines had cut paper and production costs. Speaking at Publishing Expo, he said that optimum manufacturing efficiency was the way to overcome increasing paper prices.

Emap's solution has been to implement back-to-back printing across the portfolio of 13 weeklies and 12 monthlies plus supplements. This means that sections are printed in one run, with only one makeready, on the same stock.
"We're maximising print efficiencies, minimising grammages, minimising reel sizes, bulk purchasing, reducing
makereadies and plate changes with the environmental benefits of paper and ink reduction," said Hunt.

Times have changed and priorities have shifted, according to Chris King, production director at PrintWeek's publisher Haymarket Media. "Previously, we concentrated on quality as number one, followed by the environment and costs. Now all our energies are focused on costs. In the past two years, we have conducted a bottom-up review of our supply chain," explains King.

There are plenty of areas in the production process that can be considered in such a review, paper choice being just the tip of the iceberg. "Changing trim sizes and schedules for maximum press utilisation has also been a successful way for our customers to reduce their production costs," says Polestar's Jenkins.

"We encourage our customers to carefully consider paginations to ensure the maximum number of pages on a sheet with minimum waste," explains Jones. "Ideally, for a sheetfed process, a job would be made up of 16pp sections. Other straightforward considerations include whether the title should be perfect bound or saddle stitched and could the magazine be a self-cover publication."

Cover savings
Cover changes can also help save the pennies. A high-gloss aqueous machine seal can replace a UV varnish; it may have 20% less gloss but it is an acceptable replacement plus it can reduce costs.

"Another example of potential cost saving is polywrapping and mailing," says Pensord's Jones. "Lower micron polyester
is more robust and generates more impressions per kilogram, which has a positive impact on both the environment
and cost."

Mailing can represent a significant chunk of savings, especially with several alternative postal operators. "We are also able to offer ‘downstream access' for publishers to further reduce their mailing costs and we have worked extensively with our B2B customers on this initiative," explains Polestar's Jenkins.

"There are far more postal options available now and it is possible to gain substantial savings from alternative providers to the Royal Mail," adds Jones. "However, as there are minimum restrictions to qualify, this may not benefit all publishers' mailings."

It all adds up to a pretty significant chunk of savings. Hay­market's King claims the publisher has saved in excess of £1m as a result of the firm's review. "If you look after the pennies, you are sure to save the pounds and there are a lot more savings in the pipeline," he explains. "A good production team can make the difference between magazine survival and closure."

But when the recession ends, will everything go back to how they were? Not necessarily, says King. "In my experience, if you make that many cost savings then around 75% of those changes will be permanent - you've taken the cost base down to a new level and you won't go back. That said, when the recession is over, I would like to upgrade the paper. In my opinion, 25% of those savings should be reinvested in improving the quality of the product."

The recession looks set to leave a different magazine market in its wake. Publishers have cut costs to keep many of their titles going, but how many of these measures will remain when things pick up remains to be seen.
____________________________________________
COST CUTTING: KEY AREAS

  • Simply changing the day a magazine is printed on can save publishers money - for example, switching production to a Sunday or a Monday instead of a Tuesday. Also some publishers have found that by paying their printers upfront and early, they have been able to secure discounts
  • Paginations need to be carefully considered to ensure the maximum number of pages on a sheet. The reduction in print runs can also result in a change in the way a job is done. A print run of 15,000 could be printed using web offset. If that run goes down to around 10,000 then it can go on a sheetfed press. The process changes as well as the specification of the magazines
  • Press days on weekly and monthly titles can be consolidated. For example, Emap has switched to back-to-back printing; titles are printed in one run with only one makeready on the same stock
  • Publishers are aiming to minimise the grammages on titles, as well as lowering the trim size
  • Finishing can save the pennies. By switching from perfect-bound to saddlestitch, costs can be halved. Also, covers can be a factor. While people generally might not be able to tell the difference between a UV varnish and a gloss laminate, there is a difference in price. UV varnish can be replaced with a high-gloss aqueous machine seal; it may have 20% less gloss, but it is a cheaper and, for many, an acceptable replacement
  • Lower micron poly is more robust and generates more impressions per kilogram - this benefits not only the bank balance, but also the environment
  • Mailing costs can come down by looking at alternatives to Royal Mail. By shopping around for deals from the likes of DX, CitiPost, TNT and DHL, savings can be made. Also, by physically reducing the size of the magazine, savings can be made on Royal Mail's size-based pricing policy. For example, Haymarket Publishing switched Marketing to A4 from A3 to take advantage of this
  • In pre-press, soft proofing can help publishers make further savings in paper and ink

Fujifilm FLH-Z 125


Phil Ashcroft, pre-press manager at Boxes GH, has reduced his use of replenisher by 87.5% and has saved time with this CTP plate processor ____________________________________________________________________

What does the machine do?

The FLH-Z 125 is a CTP plate processor designed primarily for use with Fujifilm Brillia HD LH-PJE positive working thermal CTP plates. It incorporates Fujifilm's latest intelligent ZAC microprocessor control system, which helps to achieve consistent, high-quality plate production while minimising chemistry and water use.

Why did you choose this particular machine?
We decided to implement CTP in order to meet customer demands for faster turnaround and to cater for decreasing run-lengths. The fantastic result in terms of quality and dot sharpness, together with Fujifilm's good reputation for reliability and after-sales service, made it the obvious choice.

Did you look at any other similar machines?
We had a look to see what other processors were available on the market, but were drawn to Fujifilm from the outset.


Why did you make the purchase?
The equipment we had on site at the time was not sufficient to keep up with rising customer demand and we did not want to fall behind any of our competitors.

What features do you particularly like?

The ZAC processor produces a perfect plate every time. It is also easy-to-use and very easy to maintain. In addition, we like the fact that it tells you about any problems through the ‘developer alarms' on the machine.


Is there anything that you dislike?

There is nothing to dislike.


Is there anything that you wish it had that it doesn't?
The processor does everything that it is supposed to do at a very high-quality - it doesn't need additional options.

How fast is it?

The processor more than keeps up with our current platesetter, which images eight large plates per hour.


How reliable is it?

It has been very reliable so far, with no problems.


What's the quality like?
Exceptional - the plates are always consistently high quality.

How easy is it to use?

The processor is very user-friendly and easy to use. The operators also received thorough training when it was first installed.

How much time or money has it saved?
With our previous processor, we used 80 litres of replenisher per month. Now we only use 10 litres per month - providing a saving of 87.5%. Also, it used to take around 10 minutes to develop a plate with our previous processor - now it takes two.

Has it won you any new work?
It hasn't yet won us any new work, although we can now take on more due to faster makeready times.

Would you say that it offers value for money?

Yes, definitely.
None whatsoever.

What about the pre- and after-sale service?
Fujifilm provided us with all the necessary information beforehand and were always just a phone call away.

Who do you think the machine is right for?

The processor is perfect for any printer using CTP. Our plates are for wide-format, but we also put our smaller plates through the processor.


Under what circumstances would you buy another?

We do not have the capacity at the moment to buy new presses [and increase capacity], so we will replace this processor at the end of its lifespan.
__________________________________________________________________

Conclusion
User's verdict
Speed 4/5 Quality 4/5 Reliability 4/5 Value for money 4/5

Supplier's response

Graham Leeson, Fujifilm marketing manager, says: "For a relatively low investment, the combination of our ‘ZAC' processor with the Brillia HD LH-PJE plate can make a real impact for printers in terms of reducing costs and improving their environmental footprint. The large reductions in chemistry that can be achieved, as highlighted by Boxes GH, together with a much simpler maintenance regime tick all the right boxes for printers, particularly in the current climate."

Price From
£20,000 Contact Fujifilm UK 01234 245245

KBA Rapida 105


This B1 press set the benchmark for frame design and incorporated a range of high-tech features that ensured its success, finds Nosmot Gbadamosi
____________________________________________________________________
Sticking to its tried and tested blueprint was KBA's strategy when designing the Rapida 105. The single piece printing unit frame, now an industry standard, was based on a design from 1965, but underneath the skin was a B1 press that featured some of the most cutting edge technology available at the time.

"When KBA developed the Rapida 105, it created the first genuine B1 hybrid - a highly productive core machine with sophisticated technical options that could be configured to excel in particular work profiles, such as commercial, packaging, labels, magazine and book printing," says KBA UK executive sales director Mark Nixon.

Introduced to coincide with the German manufacturer's centenary in 1998, the 105 boasted full automation, ­including gripper and format changes. To date, there have been 40 machines installed in the UK and more than 500 worldwide.
"It achieved worldwide success and high-quality used models can be sourced globally," says Dean Beckett, sales director of Direct Press Marketing (DPM), a UK-based used press dealer. "When you take into account the reliability, productivity and energy-efficiency of these machines, you have to rate them as excellent value and sound investments."

Additional options

The press could be configured with up to 12 printing units and additional single or multiple anilox coating units were available, along with a full suite of automation options. These ranged from program and format pre-selection at the console to fully automatic plate changing.

A comprehensive range of optional extras allowed the user to handle a full range of substrates and applications. These included: non-stop pile-changing for the feeder and delivery; semi- or fully-automatic plate changing; plinths and raised foundations; various integrated washing and drying systems to suit a whole range of inks; advanced cooling and temperature control systems; and the option of perfecting stocks up to 0.7mm.

At Drupa 2004, the 105 was radically redeveloped in a bid to stay at the forefront of press technology. The original became known as the 105 Universal, while the new Rapida 105 was the world's first press without sidelays in the feeder. Sidelay action was carried out by the grippers on the feed drum and a single wide-suction belt allowed for the reverse gathering of sheets back to the pile.

Shorter makeready
A console program on the machine allowed unused inking units to be mechanically disengaged from the press drive. This resulted in shorter wash-up times, longer service life for the rollers and more efficient makeready.

Although the 105 has been superseded by the Rapida 106, which was launched at Drupa last year, KBA still ­manufactures the press. "The next-generation Rapida 106 has become KBA's new technology trail-blazer, with Drivetronic SPC direct plate cylinder drives, but the refined version of the 105 is still in production because it is a highly competitive B1 printing press by any standards," says Nixon.

A full range of spare parts and many ancillaries are readily available direct from KBA or via secondhand dealers such
as DPM.

"DPM's sister company DMD Graphic Services has been working closely with KBA in the UK and Europe over the past six years, building expertise in both young and older models," explains DPM's Beckett.
____________________________________________________________________
Specifications
Max printing speed
15,000sph/16,500sph (DOC)
Max sheet size
720x1,050mm (DOC)
Max printing area
730x1,030mm (DOC)
Feeder pile height
1,300mm
Substrate thickness
0.06-1.6 mm
Price
New Rapida 105 5-colour £700,000
2001 Rapida 105 5-colour £300,000
What to look for
· Coating unit represents a better investment
· Temperature control for resale overseas

Friday, April 10, 2009

Digitally printed newspapers are old news for printer looking for growth

Steve Brown tells Adam Hooker how he is bucking the trend and making a success of newspaper printing.
________________________________________________________

Over the past few months, a lot of column inches in the pages of PrintWeek have been dedicated to the digital printing of newspapers. Several publishers are looking at digital as a means of getting their product printed overseas, and it has even been discussed as an alternative for getting national newspapers into remote areas of the country without the distribution costs and time lag.

However, in one corner of west London, the talk of digitally printed newspapers as a novelty has come as quite a surprise. Stroma has been printing newspapers digitally since 2001, and this month the company celebrated its five-millionth newspaper coming off the presses.

Stroma operates as part of Océ’s Digital Newspaper Network (DNN), although recently it has sought business in its own right. Months after its foundation, Stroma was approached by Océ to print a foreign title in the UK. Frustrated with existing delivery times, one Océ client, Swiss newspaper NZZ, wanted its titles available in London first thing.

Eight years later and Stroma has 400 titles from all corners of the globe on its books, eight of which are printed every day as part of the DNN, while others are produced on an ad hoc basis, as and when they are needed. Overall, the company outputs 60 to 70 titles each day.

Stroma prints between five and 500 copies in each run but, according to managing director Steve Brown, the exact requirements for each job depend on who is staying in which part of London.

Papers go to places such as foreign embassies and chambers of commerce, hotels and airports. Stroma has handled the distribution for the latter two areas itself, but for a company with just 10 employees, establishing itself has been tough.

Brown says: Hotels are a growing market, but it’s a slow growth. Not everyone knows it’s a service that’s available. But we can offer an added value for a hotel’s customer. It’s just a case of spreading the word, but we do find the response always tends to be positive.

Plans taking off
Airport business is another key area for Stroma, with around 25% of its newspapers going to that market. In order to ensure it succeeds in the sector, the company moved from Park Royal to Southall, closer to Heathrow, a year ago and it now shares its facility with newspaper logistics company Higgs – no coincidental relationship. Brown is currently forging other relationships that will boost the volume of global national newspapers printed specifically for aircrafts.

He says: It’s not just about giving the passengers in first class and business class an alternative to The Sun, it’s about making them feel at home.

We also have the possibility to include a one-page advert in there, usually towards the back in place of a redundant ads page. We can include an advert for the airline, for example, a special offer or some other service they offer.

Brown also has plans to upgrade the company’s current Demandstream 8090 press with Océ Jetstream technology by the end of the year. The major benefit of this will be the ability to offer colour newspapers, which could offer the key to taking Stroma’s newspaper business to the next level.

He says: The machine would improve our speed, but colour has always been a major stumbling block. Publishing is led by advertising and without colour, advertising is an issue. We have been waiting for this opportunity and I think the introduction of colour will lead to a bit of a surge – I can see newspapers growing to 50-60% of our total business.

Increasing newspaper printing could be coming at a perfect time, with the industry as a whole undergoing a widespread change, not least in its distribution techniques.

Brown explains: Distributors are moving away from the sale and return model because of the cost of pulping, administration and transport for the unsold copies. With digital printing we are encouraging people to only take as many newspapers as they will need. It has happened naturally.

Perhaps mindful of the challenges currently facing the sector, Brown doesn’t overplay the importance of papers to his business, but when Stroma is able to print in colour, global publishers, hotels and airlines, are certain to come flocking.

As traditional newspaper printers continue to struggle and close plants, Stroma will increase its portfolio of publications, print runs and destinations. And, as the rest of the newspaper industry continues to talk about digitally printing newspapers, Stroma will just get on with doing it.
________________________________________________________

STROMA FACTFILE


Based Southall, west London
Founded 2001
Managing director Steve Brown
Turnover £2m
Areas covered newspapers, training manuals
Kit Océ Demandstream 8090

Is digital packing a punch?

Despite lingering concerns over speed, price and spot colours,many believe digital has potential for the packaging sector, says Philip Chadwick

Although digital print is widely accepted in the commercial print market, it’s a tougher sell in packaging. With runs generally longer and colour management critical, traditional processes such as flexo, litho and gravure have held up strongly.

However, there are signs that the latest developments in both inkjet and toner-based technology are slowly starting to make in-roads in the packaging sector. In labels, digital is very much an accepted technology, while in the cartons market there are signs that the big names are making concerted efforts to gain a bigger slice of the action. The technology is still at a formative stage, but in years to come, a packaging printer is as likely to have a digital press in its armoury as it is a flexo press.

It is testament to how digital technology has evolved, that it has now become a viable option for packaging firms. In the past the quality and speed of the print wasn’t up to the standards of gravure or flexo, while run lengths were also an issue. However, this is changing, with digital presses getting up to speed (although still not quick enough for long-run packaging) and the print quality significantly increasing.

Mark Stephenson, Fuji UK sales manager for digital solutions, says even today, if you directly compare a piece of digital print with, say, gravure, under close scrutiny you can still tell them apart. In isolation, that’s not the case. There are still people who check things over with an eyeglass, but sometimes you can get too caught up with that. At first glance, often people would be stuck to tell if it is a digital print or not.

Personalised options
In addition to the ability to produce high-quality work, digital printing offers practicalities such as tighter turnaround times and shorter run lengths, and this can be key when it comes to marketing. Manufacturers believe their products can really triumph when it comes to special, limited-edition packaging or labels, with variable data offering a range of personalised options. And they have not been slow in developing presses that can muscle in on a market that is traditionally dominated by a blend of gravure, flexo and litho. In the toner-based market, HP, Xeikon and Xerox have all been actively developing their presses.

In Xeikon’s case, the time and money spent targeting the labels market has paid off. The manufacturer, part of Punch Graphix, has found that sales are holding up strongly. We are selling lots of machines – it is outstripping other markets, says Greg Neesham, Punch Graphix UK sales director. Our view is that the self-adhesive labels market is more mature and resilient to the recession.

Neesham believes that digital is proving to be such a success in the market that it’s now eating into flexo. Combining shorter runs with alternative image designs in that run has meant that label printers can be more flexible. Instead of doing a run of 1m labels, you can now just do 20,000. There are also a host of variations, he says.

Barry Griffiths, director at Rhyl-based Borble, agrees. His firm was the first in the UK to install Xeikon’s 3300 (see box). With digital, you can do tens of different designs in one short run, Griffiths says. The print quality is also good from the faintest highlight to the deepest solid colour.

Digital developments
Developments in the toner market haven’t just been limited to labels. At last year’s Drupa, there was a new press targeting the pharmaceutical and cosmetics markets.

The Gallop has in-line options for varnishing, stacking, conveying and die-cutting. Xerox linked up with Stora Enso to develop the product, which consists of an iGen3 press, an Epic CT0-635 varnishing unit with aqueous and UV options, and a Kama die-cutter for a sheet size of 580x400mm. Stora Enso’s Tambrite, Ensocoat and Ensogloss boards were tested and approved for iGen3 use by Xerox.

There is a lot of interest in the machine, explains Fuji’s Stephenson. It’s ideal for the trialling of a new line of cosmetic or pharmaceutical products. What gives the Gallop the advantage is that it can do embossing and foil-stamping.

Typically, digital is for the short-run market but Stephenson says runs on the Gallop can be quite high in the case of packaging, ranging from 2,000 up to 20,000. What digital also lends itself well to is the prototype – the packaging can be effectively road-tested before it goes into general production.

As well as xerographic, Fuji has a foot in the inkjet market, thanks to its Dimatix printhead, which goes up against other well-established players such as Xaar. The latter’s latest printhead, the 1001, was developed for use in industries such as packaging, textiles, ceramics and printed electronics. It incorporates Xaar’s drop-on-demand technology and was designed to handle difficult fluids such as white or metallic inks.

Another manufacturer to have latched onto the latest technology is Nilpeter. With technology partners Xaar and FFEI, the company unveiled the Caslon in 2007 – a conventional narrow-web flexo press with an inkjet unit.

We have combined the printing technology to optimise the cost per label, explains FFEI managing director Andy Cook. We have hit the sweet spot for the Nilpeter customer.

For the label market, digital isn’t new, but using inkjet technology is. The next challenge is to push on into new markets. FFEI is looking at adapting the technology for niche applications such as DVD covers, pharmaceutical products and cosmetics packaging.

Overcoming obstacles
The challenge is the text, adds Cook. We can use some screening technology to enhance the text, but inkjet is a non-impact technology. Trying to get a crisp finish to the text is challenging.

And that’s not the only hurdle the digital sector must climb when it comes down to packaging. The sector loves spot colours and that’s difficult to change on digital especially on the short runs, explains Fuji’s Stephenson. Then there is the cost-per-copy issue – digital is better suited to special packaging and one-offs as well as prototypes.

Speed is also an issue. To run an inkjet machine at 25m per minute may suit short runs, but the technology simply can’t compete with the speeds of gravure or flexo.

Cook believes there is still a lot of work that can be done to make digital a credible option for packaging printers. We are still playing around with the technology. There are lots of technical issues but there are plenty of niche markets that are well suited to digital.

Stephenson agrees, adding that the market is realising the quality of digital has matured. There are some great ideas out there and people are bringing all the elements together; it is a challenge, but the interest is high.

With the labels market now well and truly embracing digital, only time will tell when sectors like cartonboard and flexible packaging can go right up against more traditional processes. Expect next year’s Ipex to be a good indication of how far digital has come.
__________________________________________________________

CASE STUDY (BORBLE)

The story behind Rhyl-based Borble is as much a lesson about planning as it is the digital technology used in the labels market. Co-founder and director Barry Griffiths had a background in gravure print for flexible packaging, but by 2004 he had spotted the potential benefits of digital.

Digital print by then had become industrially viable, he says. By August 2004, I had written a business plan based on an emerging shift in the labels market. People wanted to have shorter runs and a wider variety of labels. They didn’t want their cash tied up with stock on the shelf.

With the bank giving the business the green light, Borble made its first investment with a Xeikon 330. According to Griffiths, HP was also considered but the company went for Xeikon because the 330 met the criteria we wanted. Since then, Borble has gone on to become the first UK firm to install a Xeikon 3300 and has been able to carve out a few niches.

Small independent food manufacturers have called upon Borble’s services, as well as print brokers and some printers themselves. We are targeting small markets and that suits us, adds Griffiths.

Digital print has also given Borble’s clients the chance to view labels before they go to the market – a form of prototyping.

Griffiths adds that digital technology allows you to do this thanks to the ability to do very short runs and the faster makeready times. By not using plates you are saving money and eliminating the disposal of those plates, which is also good for the environment.

Offset-saturated regions are opting for inkjet as the digital divide is drawn up

I am currently reassessing the relationship between digital and litho printing. Two interesting reports, one from Gartner and one from Infotrends, have recently been released on the position of digital printing compared with offset printing.

I also received some interesting data from vice president and general manager of the HP Indigo Press division Alon Bar-Shany that looked at the sales of offset and high-end digital presses. The figures show estimated sales in the different parts of the world for B1-, B2- and B3-format offset presses and for high-end digital presses.

These figures show the major market for offset presses is the rest of the world (ROW) – ie not North America, Europe or the Middle East and Africa (EMEA). It also shows that digital press sales were high in both EMEA and North America, but relatively low in ROW.

It may be that both North America and Europe have reached a high saturation level of modern offset presses based upon the substantial contraction of the printing industry in those areas, whereas the ROW areas are still expanding their traditional print markets. The ROW figures may also be skewed when one takes account of the large number of used presses that are sold in this area.

Digital dominance
The figures given by HP only cover the top of the market. If one were to extend these figures to cover the mid-range digital presses, with duty cycles between 300,000 and one million that predominantly sell into the graphic arts markets, then the volume of digital presses increases substantially. These products tend to sell at least double the volume of the high-end presses.

In 2007, Infotrends research showed sales of 2,572 such units in US and Europe. On that basis, I’d estimate that 2008 sales for such products would be 3,500 units and this would make the total sales of digital presses predominantly sold to graphic arts markets in 2008 to be in excess of 5,000 units.

Extrapolating these figures further, one could estimate that the total money spent on digital presses by the graphic arts markets in 2008 exceeded that spent on offset presses. If that is the case, then 2008 is a milestone year in the transition to digital printing.

Gartner, a major IT information company, has just completed a study of 443 production print managers in the US, France, Germany, and the UK that provides convincing evidence that, for the first time, long-held preferences for offset printing have been up-ended.

The Gartner study was designed to provide evidence of the perceived differences between the four main printing technologies. The respondents were asked to rate the image quality of different technologies on a scale of 1-7. The results from this showed the following: dry toner 5.68, liquid ink (Indigo) 5.40, inkjet 5.24 and offset 5.17. The study also asked recipients to assess work in terms of value and the results were as follows: toner 5.58, liquid ink 5.29, inkjet 5.23 and offset 5.13. This report shows that digital printing is no longer seen as a poor equivalent of offset printing.

The Infotrends report looked at the comparative costs of digital and offset printing. It analysed a number of different jobs and calculated the total costs of these when printed on a four-colour 74cm press and an HP Indigo 7000 digital press. It calculated the crossover point in terms of run length between the two technologies and the actual time to run the complete jobs.

The overall results showed a saving in time of 30 hours using digital printing. The crossover points where it became more economical to print offset for a specific product ranged from 1,130 copies for a book to 22,000 copies for a postcard.
What these reports show is that digital is taking an increasing share of work away from offset printing – the reduction in time if using digital is a critical factor.

This must all be glum reading for the offset press suppliers. It will get worse as the wider-format colour inkjet presses such as the HP Inkjet Web Press and the forthcoming Kodak Stream press, that are aimed at the graphic arts quality markets, move digital far further into the offset space when they become available next year.

Andrew Tribute is a journalist and consultant in digital and pre-press and pre-media technology. Visit www.attributes.co.uk

Take a small step to show success

Budgets are tight and extravagant spending is on hold, but the small and smart investment can still make all the difference.
______________________________________________________

Sometimes less is more. With companies choosing to postpone major investments in kit, there has been a shift towards devices and software that don’t cost the earth but could save a considerable amount of money in the long term. At this year’s Northprint, on 21-23 April at the Harrogate Exhibition Centre, exhibitors are expecting a surge of interest in equipment that makes printers’ businesses more efficient, getting maximum return on investment for minimal outlay.


That’s not to say that the days of big spending big are gone, but with print firms under pressure like never before, they have less money to spend and are being more watchful with resources. They are looking to get more out of their existing presses, while hopefully spending only a few thousand pounds on kit that adds value. That’s good news for manufacturers and distributors in the digital, post-press and workflow markets, because these are the kind of products that could make all the difference.

According to Duplo UK marketing manager Peter Jolly, the current economic climate has led many printers to invest in kit to bring finishing in-house. Outsourcing certain aspects of a job, such as UV coating or perfect binding, are a thing of the past, he says. Today, the machines involved are less daunting and fairly automated. By offering a range of diverse finishing options, printers are attracting more business.

Mature market
The maturity of the digital market has also helped. It’s now more cost-effective to print shorter runs digitally, plus there’s the added bonus of incorporating variable data. Companies are making investments and we aren’t short of firms wanting to do business with us, says Konica Minolta head of production print Clare Revell. Personalisation software complements the digital press. Companies are looking to work smarter. It is very seldom that we just sell a piece of equipment on its own.

This is echoed by Ricoh product manager for professional print products Gareth Parker. He says companies are cutting their cloth where appropriate and for Ricoh, that means guiding them towards workflow products.

We explain that the next step for customers is workflow – it’s an area that can’t be ignored, he says. It doesn’t have to be a multimillion-pound product.

At last year’s Total Print! Expo, Ricoh launched hardware; for Northprint, the focus is workflow. It’s a four-pronged approach: job submission and ordering; document composition; workflow authoring; and digital services. Ricoh has spotted a clear sign of interest in the first area. Job submission lends itself to web-to-print software and Parker notes there has been significant interest in this area.

There’s a plethora of opportunities, he adds. It’s an area that is only going to expand because the e-commerce generation is demanding it. The technology is not prohibitive for the smaller players in the print market, but it does need some careful consideration. You need to have the appropriate system for your business.

It’s a sign of the times that a digital press manufacturer such as Ricoh is now talking up the benefits of software. But that’s not to say the hardware side will be ignored at Northprint. Konica Minolta is showing some equipment that it unveiled at last year’s Drupa, but hasn’t been demonstrated before in the UK.

We were keen to support Northprint and demonstrate our products even though it is a difficult time, adds Revell. It’s made us more focused as time is precious for visitors. But no one visits the show unless they’re planning to invest in the near future.
Post-press focused
The maturity of the digital market has also had a knock-on effect for other sectors. In post-press, there is growing interest in smaller devices for short runs. We’ve seen the strength of the digital guys in the front end, and this has put more pressure on us to develop faster makeready machines with more automation for both entry-level and heavy production, says Renz UK sales and marketing manager Daniel Pooley.

Renz intends to demonstrate what it says is the world’s first fully automated bench-top punch, the DTP 360.
So far, Pooley claims these kind of systems are selling well because they allow printers to get into wire binding at a relatively low price. Systems like Onepitch allow users to bind from a few sheets up to 340, all from one machine, he adds.

Jolly says that following the digital boom, Duplo has invested a lot of time and money on research and development to cash in on demand for products that suit all budgets. The market is currently shifting towards digital print with many printers offering shorter print runs. [As a result] we have had to expand our range so we have something to offer every type of printer, he explains.

Multitasking machines
Versatile devices are also becoming increasingly popular. For example, Duplo’s DC 645 multi-finisher effectively combines the work of three machines into one – it cuts, slits, creases and perforates. Jolly claims the machine doesn’t just save time and money, but also floor space.

In the past, the 645 may only have been used for finishing business cards. Many customers are now thinking of ways to branch out and offer more with this machine, such as wedding stationery, says Jolly.

But it’s not just about buying new kit. Getting the most out of your existing equipment can be just as important and cost-effective. This is the view of first-time exhibitor Humidity Solutions. Sales director John Barker explains that having a stable humidity level can lengthen the production life of litho or digital presses.

Humidity is a desirable thing and prevents paper curl. The substrate does not change dimension and means less downtime, he says. We offer systems for everything from small digital print applications up to large press halls. His firm is taking advantage of firms being more frugal. People are tweaking their systems rather than going for wholesale change.

Views from visitors
Nicky Mason, managing director of event organiser IIR Exhibitions, says Northprint will offer visitors better ways of doing business. When we were deciding whether to run the event, we felt it had delivered such good results for so many exhibitors and visitors for over 40 years. It would be a shame for us just to walk away and give in to recessionary pressures.

She is adamant that trade shows have an important role to play in the current climate, as is Ian Forsyth, co-founder of Lancashire digital trade printer Forsyth & Steele. He says: We’re big fans of printing shows. They are an important way of stepping out of your business and keeping in touch with how other people’s businesses run.

Stuart Mason, founder and managing director of Scottish quickprint franchise Inkshop Printing, agrees, adding that it’s worth visiting shows like Northprint if only to see what’s on offer – you never know what you might find.

We’re hearing about so much doom and gloom. But there are some really good deals out there. It would be such a negative thing for the printing industry if Northprint didn’t go ahead, says Mason.

Spotting good deals, especially ones that won’t cost the earth, is what Northprint is all about this year. The theme is building business, which is apt in a sector where times are tough and a small change really can make a big difference.
______________________________________________________

SHOW INFORMATION

Where Harrogate Exhibition Centre
When 21 -23 April 2009
Hours
Tues 10.00–17.00
Weds 10.00–17.00
Thurs 10.00–16.00

Register and directions www.northprintexpo.co.ukHow to get there
Harrogate is off the A1 just north of Leeds. It is 200 miles from London and Edinburgh and is served by a fast train from both. London to Harrogate via York takes around two-and-a-half hours

By road
Sat nav HG1 5LA
From the south M1 then A1 (M) – exit Wetherby (Harrogate: nine miles)
From the north A1 – exit Wetherby or Knaresborough (Harrogate: eight miles)
From the east M621-A1 (M) – exit Wetherby
From the west M56-M62-A1 (M) – exit Wetherby

Parking
New and improved parking facilities are now available, with 450 new parking spaces five minutes from Harrogate International Centre. The venue also has another 450 parking spaces while the train station has a further 780 spaces. For further parking information, please contact Harrogate Tourist Information on 01423 537300

By rail
Regular rail services operate to Harrogate via York and Leeds

By air
BMI operates regular flights from both Edinburgh and Glasgow to Leeds-Bradford International Airport, which is a 20-minute drive from Harrogate International Centre

Me & My: Glunz & Jensen PlateWriter 2000

Stuart Way, co-owner of Speedprint UK, has reduced company production times by up to 50% with this easy-to-use, low-cost metal platesetter _____________________________________________________________

What does the machine do?

The PlateWriter 2000 produces metal litho printing plates direct from the computer without the need for any processing chemicals.

Why did you choose this particular machine?
Because of the low cost, small size and ease of use for experienced and inexperienced staff.

Did you look at any other similar machines?

We looked at a few secondhand CTP systems.

Why did you make the purchase?
To replace an older manual system.

What features do you particularly like?

The ability to print from any operating system and programme. The ease of use in the RIP is also beneficial.

Is there anything that you dislike?

No.

Is there anything that you wish it had that it doesn’t?

No.

How fast is it?

We can produce an average of eight plates an hour.

How reliable is it?

It’s a very reliable machine.

What’s the quality like?

The quality is exactly the same as a conventional metal CTP system. We have compared both side-by-side and cannot find any difference.

How easy is it to use?

Very easy. The hardest thing is printing from the programmes.

How much time or money has it saved?
It has cut production time by 30%, but the cost of producing a plate on a consumable basis is about the same. However, when taking into account the labour cost, then you could say we have saved about 50% on production time.

Has it won you any new work?

No.

Would you say that it offers value for money?

Yes, very much so.

Were there any difficulties experienced during the installation or after?

We have had no difficulties at all. We have been running the PlateWriter 2000 for around four months now and we have not required any contact with technical support or needed any other services.

What about the pre- and after-sale service?

It has been excellent.

Who do you think the machine is right for?

Small offset printers running anything from 50 to 600 plates a month.

Under what circumstances would you buy another?

If we needed to accommodate an increase in plate size or capacity. _____________________________________________________________

CONCLUSION


User’s verdict
Speed 5/5 Quality 5/5 Reliability 5/5 Value for money 5/5

Supplier’s response
Ian Melville, managing director of Info-Tec Distribution, says: For small to medium-sized commercial printers like Speedprint, an affordable in-house high-quality metal CTP system is an essential part of production. The Glunz and Jensen iCTP systems offer a cost-effective, easy-to-use and processor/chemical-free method of producing plates. The PlateWriter 2000 has enabled Speedprint UK to reduce overheads and improve the efficiency of their plate production.
Price
On application
Contact
Info-Tec Distribution 01202 845960

Monday, December 15, 2008

In Depth: Spending wisely


For many years, overcapacity in the paper industry has made it a buyer's market, and printers benefited. But in the present economic climate, paper mills, like printers, are having a tough time of it, mainly due to rising raw materials and energy costs. In the past year, things have come to a head, with a succession of mills closing. This has led to a reduction in capacity, which has pushed prices up. Paper typically represents 20-50% of the total cost of a print job, depending on the type of work and run length and, in light of the current circumstances, that percentage may well go up.
We’ve been through a round of price increases in a year that is unlike anything seen before, says PaperCo marketing director Bob Ide. There were rises in February, June, July and September covering all grades and amounting to around 14-15%. Underlying that has been an unprecedented rise in costs.Unfortunately for printers, it isn’t the best time to be attempting to pass these price rises onto customers.A lot of the products we make are for retailers and they’re having a really torrid time – we find it nearly impossible to go to those customers and say ‘prices are going up’, says Sherwood Press commercial director Richard Bacon.While it may feel like they’re stuck between a rock and a hard place, there are ways for printers to cut their paper prices and relieve some of the pressure; ways that don’t require elaborate financial strategies and the use of a crystal ball – it isn’t necessary to think about hedging or relentlessly following commodity prices.Part of Bacon’s solution at Sherwood Press has been to buy smarter. For several years, the firm has used professional procurement processes to save money by buying in a more intelligent way. He used the Vision in Print (ViP) Materials, Consumables and Services Purchasing Best Practice Guide (see box), which was published back in 2005, as his model and has reaped six-figure annual savings as a result.


Change in purpose

When Bacon first adopted professional procurement, it reduced the prices he was paying. Subsequently, it has become a tool to prevent prices rises and now he uses different buying approaches for different products. We buy 70% of our paper on long-term contract, 20% from preferred suppliers and 10% spot buying, says Bacon. We have paper contracts for contract print work, where we know the volumes and the grade. It’s really helped us, as the rest of the industry has had three or four rises in the region of 10-16%. Bacon admits that contracts don’t work for jobbing print, but he says that he has gained savings through a preferred supplier arrangement with two companies for board and two companies for paper. Bacon tends to buy his remaining spot purchases from these firms too, as they offer the best deals. You may think that these sorts of savings achieved through smarter procurement were only available to larger firms, but that’s not the case, according to James McNaughton Group marketing director Tony Porter. Not a great deal of printers work in this way, most work on a job-by-job basis, but the level of saving could be up to 10%. Northamptonshire-based The Direct Printing Company (TDPC) is an example of a smaller firm reaping the benefits. The £1.1m-turnover outfit started employing the ViP techniques this year, putting contracts in place in October. Commercial manager Rachel Tait says that it has resulted in a saving of 10% in the prices it pays for paper.While Antalis marketing manager James Jarvis cautions that the cost savings may not be as high for everyone, they are still significant. In commodity grades, you’d be lucky to get a couple of percent, he says. If you get 5% off, you’re doing well. But bearing in mind that paper is typically 30% of a job’s cost, it’s still worth it.Anyone tempted to go down this route should be aware that it can be a time-consuming process. It took time to tender and it took a long time to analyse the results and test the suggested stocks, says TDPC’s Tait. It takes four months, estimates Bacon. You need to get the tenders out and to do your homework. However, Tait believes that, in the long term, it ends up saving time and delivering other benefits. It’s simplified internal procedures, as now people know what to buy, she says. We’ve also switched to online ordering. Our purchasers save a couple of hours each day now that they’re no longer constantly searching for the best price. It also speeds up estimating.


Online deals

Antalis’s Jarvis points out that constantly calling to check prices or make orders costs the merchant too, which will affect paper prices. Although we love talking to our customers, if you’re on the phone to us three or four times per day, that all costs money, he says. Look at online trading. If you do a price review, we could let you buy electronically.Another tip to save both sides administration costs is to opt for consolidated monthly invoices. Merchants emphasise the importance of being more open with them to gain better pricing and other benefits.The most success we have in reducing prices is when the customer lets us into their business, says McNaughton’s Porter. It helps if we can come in and do a paper audit. We can show the customer what they buy most frequently and consolidate that.Jarvis concurs, adding: Many firms don’t even know how much they buy month-by-month. Once you have a handle on your requirements, it’s possible to get a saving through looking at logistics and taking bigger deliveries less often. Most of our costs are in logistics, so the more we can put on a vehicle the better, says Jarvis.Bacon agrees this approach is key: You need to be able to give something back. Look at your business and see if you can consolidate deliveries to save your supplier’s transport costs.Beyond better buying, there are further ways to save. For instance, most merchants offer smaller sheet sizes or custom sizes and, even if custom sheeting adds a small premium, they argue it’s more than covered by the reduced tonnage bought. There are also bulkier stocks, which are thicker – that is, have a bigger caliper than standard for a given grammage, which means you get more sheets for a given weight.One customer, after ordering stock for a 20pp booklet, wanted to add 4pp without upping the cost, we supplied a bulkier grade, Claro, that delivered the additional pages for the same price, says Porter.


Best match needed

Sherwood’s Bacon has used this approach, but urges caution. If a grade’s price goes up, we spend a lot of time sourcing an alternative, he says. It needs to be as close as possible in physical properties. You have to be careful, as it could be 2,000-3,000 sheets per hour slower and not just on press, we test materials through finishing too. My advice would be to get a free pallet in from potential suppliers as part of the tendering process.While there are many things that can help identify better suppliers, being a better customer can also save you money.Many printers can be a bit slack on administration and cashflow, says Jarvis. Tighten up in those areas and you make yourself more attractive to merchants. Set payment terms and stick to them. It’s a good way to get price leverage. With paper and print facing tough times, both sectors stand to benefit from a move by printers to more professional paper purchasing.Printers use historic practices. They believe that it’s best to apply the most pressure they can. It’s macho purchasing, says Jarvis. However, he believes there are savings for both sides by taking a softer approach: It’s better to have a long-term partnership, rather than being aggressive and promiscuous.

...........................................................................................

TOP TIPS: VIP PROCUREMENT

For firms looking to benefit from a professional procurement policy, Vision in Print (ViP) published its Materials, Consumables and Services Purchasing Best Practice Guide back in June 2005. The guide outlines a four-level purchasing strategy, moving from level one, which covers basic buying processes through good discipline and supplier relationships, up to level four, which deals with integrated alliances. The guide includes a basic toolkit that firms can use to implement best practice using levels one and two and an advanced-level toolkit for the more sophisticated purchasing procedures of level three and four, which can produce greater savings.The basic toolkit covers preparation of supplier information, tenders and contracts, supplier selection, operational process and general purchasing rules. The advanced level toolkit adds additional elements for more advanced purchasing procedures including developing closer working relationships with suppliers, integrating MIS and e-commerce to streamline processes and working with suppliers to jointly identify opportunities to lower costs.The ViP Purchasing Best Practice Guide can be downloaded free from the ViP website. Although ViP doesn’t offer a specific purchasing training course, it can be chosen as the focus for its five-day Office and Pre-press Change Cycle courses.

Thursday, December 11, 2008

In-Depth: The bard of B,T&D


Multimillionaire publishing maverick Felix Dennis shocked many when he was revealed as the driving force behind the resurrection of Butler and Tanner. In his first interview with a printing magazine, Dennis explains the motives behind creating Butler, Tanner & Dennis.

I guess we should start with the big question – why did you decide to get involved with Butler and Tanner?

Felix Dennis:
I’ve been collecting books all my life and I own tens of thousands of them. I’d been seeing ‘Printed by Butler and Tanner, Frome and London’ since I was a boy and so, quite obviously, there was already quite a degree of affection for the company because I’m a book collector. And it did seem to me to be a very sad state of affairs that Britain’s only remaining high-end colour book printer should vanish.

The talent base in Frome would have been lost forever. It’s a town with printing in its blood, in its DNA, which has been printing books for 157 years. It seemed crazy that such talent should be dissipated.

But we didn’t do it for sentiment. No one does business for sentiment if they’re sensible. I do think they have a chance, I honestly do. They have a good management team in place, they have got a superb workforce and I think everybody that could have helped, has helped.

People must have thought I had completely taken leave of my senses when buying Butler and Tanner – I would imagine so anyway. But if the company ever fails again, it will not be for the want of trying.

That’s good to hear. How did the deal come about?

I heard about their troubles when we called them up to print Homeless in My Heart. They had printed a poetry book a year before for us, Island of Dreams, and they did a fabulous job, a beautiful job, and I wanted them to do my new one.

Fortunately, the person who looks after my book production, Caroline, had the B&T sales director’s mobile number and got through to him. He said: ‘We’re all locked out of the factory, we can’t print any books for you.’ We thought, what a pain. When she told me this, I went on the internet, including onto printweek.com, to familiarise myself with what was happening there, and then Caroline began getting more calls from the managers trying to effect a management buyout and I agreed to talk with them. It was a gradual process, a bit like wooing a woman really.

There’s a lot of controversy surrounding companies being bought out of administration in the print industry. Was this the only route open to you?

If you’re asking me if I would have bought Butler and Tanner before it went into the hands of the receivers, the answer is decidedly ‘no’. For a number of reasons, not least the issues with the pension fund, which had become the company’s main focus.

Then, I think, there were issues of investment and management. There were issues of redundancy payments. The whole business was so complex. It had become vitriolic with everyone blaming everybody else. It wasn’t a business that anyone would have invested in as a going concern.


Did you look at the company last summer or earlier this year, then, before it went into administration for the first and second times?

No, I did not. I’m re-engineering the past. Even if I had looked, I would certainly not have gone there. In a sense, the worst had to happen for the chance of a new start. Often people that run companies inherit problems that turn out to be insurmountable, so I don’t want to spend time apportioning blame.

So moving on, what’s your involvement with Butler, Tanner & Dennis on a day-to-day level?
I don’t run any of my companies. I ceased being a managing director in April 1983 and remember walking out of my office, which was in Rathbone Place at the time, and thinking ‘that was an interesting few years’. But I haven’t run a company since and I don’t run Butler, Tanner & Dennis, it is run by Kevin Sarney and his colleagues.

But clearly you’ve already spent a lot of money on the company, so you surely have some involvement?
Yes, we’ve spent money, and I laugh hoarsely when I see ‘Felix Dennis bought the company for half a million’. My dear, that’s what it costs to get into the nightclub – it’s buying the drinks that really knocks the stuffing out of you.

Even at my very first board meeting, the management started to do what all printers do: they started talking about new machinery. To some degree, you have to invest in new machinery as you’re always playing catch-up with the 21st Century and, yes, I agree and the binding line’s done. When will we purchase our next piece of machinery? I don’t know. I know [the management] would like to do it next week and I don’t think I will be agreeing to it for a few months. We have to get a few months of trading under our belts first and we need to be satisfying our customers – really satisfying our customers – which is the name of the game in the end.

We [Dennis and his financial director Ian Leggett] are print novices, you know. Fortunately the management team at Butler, Tanner & Dennis are not novices at all and neither are some of the grey wise heads there. We’re very good with money and cost control. We’re good at revisiting budgets, re-forecasting constantly, keeping a very, very close eye on expenditure and income. But we rely entirely on the Butler, Tanner & Dennis management team for the running of the business and I will not be interfering with it at all. I don’t do it with any of the other companies I own and won’t be interfering there either

What are your long-term goals for the company?
Do I think I will own Butler, Tanner & Dennis forever? I haven’t got a clue. I don’t know what the future will bring, I truly don’t. I’ll be delighted if the company can get back on its feet and start making a profit. One promise I have made to the management and the workforce is that there will be no repetition of secrecy and lack of transparency. Everyone that works at Butler, Tanner & Dennis, whether they want to know or not, is going to know how we’re doing. Now, I’m not trying to burden them – the management is supposed to carry that load – but on the other hand, I would rather the staff were slightly burdened than kept in the dark. I think there will be troughs as well as some peaks and it’s important that everyone knows where we stand.

We are up against the most appalling financial circumstances and there are a lot of other companies in the world that will print books. Obviously, from an environmental point of view, we think that UK publishers should print all their books with Butler, Tanner & Dennis to avoid these millions of book miles on container ships and we are hoping to persuade many authors, many famous authors, to ask their publishers to print books aimed at the UK and Europe at Butler, Tanner & Dennis rather than in Asia or far-flung corners of Europe.

Saying that, as far as the environment is concerned, all of us are hypocrites. If we got an enormous order from a West Coast publisher in the US, I can absolutely assure you we would fulfil that order and shove those books onto container ships. The UK and Europe are a big markets for books and I do think that we have that going in our favour.

Will you try to instil some of your environmental views at Butler, Tanner & Dennis? [One of Dennis’s personal projects is to create a massive native forest, The Forest of Dennis, in Warwickshire.]
Yes, I do think we can do that. I am always very careful to explain to people that don’t know anything about trees, the idiocy of shouting and screaming about the waste of printing ink on paper. If you went to Canada or Finland to see the way the trees are planted to manufacture pulp for paper, you would realise that it is a crop.

They have 12-, 15-, 20-year felling cycles, then they’re replanted. That’s why they’re some of the best-managed forests in the world. And of course, if those trees weren’t going to be used for paper, they wouldn’t have been planted and they wouldn’t be sitting there, millions and millions and millions of them with their woolly little heads for 15 years.

In fact, if we want to see more trees planted, we need to read more books, newspapers and magazines. But people get confused, they think we’re chopping down old oak trees to make wood pulp and it’s difficult sometimes to explain to people that we don’t chop down broadleaf trees to make paper.

Coming from a publishing background, you must have an understanding of the print industry?
I know nothing about the print industry except that I’ve been negotiating with them on the other side all my life. I’ve spent many years of my early working life very happily going around printers all over Britain. Actually in those days I was a very long-haired young man with loon pants and snakeskin boots and there I was climbing up these ladders on to the very first coldset web-offset machines, then on the first heatset, actually pouring ink into the troughs mixing inks, two colours one at each end of the trough, things you would never be allowed to do today.

It is easy to be beguiled by machinery and craft but I think there is a future for this company, although I think it will be very difficult. The recent collapse in financial confidence and this new recession we’re moving into hasn’t helped.

However, fortune favours the brave and from Butler, Tanner & Dennis’s point of view, the pound dropping like a stone against the dollar is like manna from Heaven.

Do you have any regrets about becoming involved with Butler and Tanner?
No question at all. We started with 80 people and that was our biggest regret: that we could only employ 80. I think we’re up to 90 now, but we’ve got to be careful not to grow too quickly if we’re to remain sustainable. It is our intention, of course, and our wish to bring the company back to a position where there will be 100, or even 200 people working back at Butler, Tanner & Dennis. But we must go very slowly and it must be desperately disappointing to the people that we can’t re-employ.

What has been the general response to the new company?
There was residue of goodwill – which I hadn’t quite realised would be there, but which I should have guessed because it is the same as my own – that came from Butler and Tanner’s relationship with its customers: the book publishers and companies for whom it prints its annual reports and fancy brochures. I was frankly astonished how many of them phoned up to say they would do everything they could to support the company. And, to be truthful, most of them have and that is very, very gratifying indeed.

And most of all, from the existing management and workforce, who made it abundantly clear that they were prepared to work until they dropped to try to assist in this rebirth and when we realised this, even though the negotiations were fraught and very difficult, I think it was at that point that there was actually a chance of kicking this off again.

Obviously, we did not expect the suppliers to be as magnanimous as many of them have now been burnt twice. I know what that is like and I know we will have to work hard for a very long time to prove ourselves to our suppliers – or at least Kevin and his team will have to work hard to prove themselves to the suppliers. But at least the company has a chance.

One final question: Clearly it’s difficult to predict the future for just one company, but based on your knowledge of e-zines, for example [Dennis publishing launched Monkey, one of the first true online-only rich-content e-zines] do you think print will be around for another 100 years?
Do I think ink on paper will survive? Yes, I think in certain categories for certain audiences for certain products. Ink on paper has a very bright future. For others, I think the content will migrate to the electronic sea.

But, I’ll give you two very swift examples in the magazine field. In books, I think it’s obvious that people will continue to read books. Many people love books, they love the portability, the tactile feel, the fact they don’t need a battery to replace them. I think books stand a very good chance of continuing for a very considerable period of time.

With magazines, I think if you take two completely different magazines, Vogue and The Week, I think both of those will survive because one, with ladies looking at frocks and accessories, nothing can beat looking at a fantastic photograph or a double-page spread printed in Vogue – it’s unbeatable. The web can’t touch it.

For The Week, it’s so convenient, roaming round the tube or on a plane. It so suits our readership to get through it – it’s a very short magazine, only 35 editorial pages every week. I think that will survive. Do I think many other types of magazines will be as lucky? I’m not so certain. I think that they will migrate to the web.

Dennis’s latest book of poetry, Homeless in my Heart, is available from Amazon.com

..................................................................................
CV Felix dennis

1947 Born in Kingston Upon Thames

1973 Founded his own magazine publishing house

1987 Co-founded Micro Warehouse

November 2002 First collection of poetry, A Glass Half Full, published

October 2003 Appeared with the Royal Shakespeare Company, reading from his work at the Swan theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon

June 2007 Sold his US magazine operation

July 2008 Butler and Tanner rebranded Butler, Tanner & Dennis following last-minute bid backed by Dennis. The Frome-based printer reopened for business, employing 80 staff, the following month

2 October 2008 Fifth poetry book Homeless in my Heart launched

23 October 2008 Performed in Frome in front of 160 employees of B,T& D and their families as part of his poetry tour, ‘Did I Mention the Free Wine?’

R U 4 Change